Current:Home > InvestLaw letting Tennessee attorney general argue certain capital cases is constitutional, court rules-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Law letting Tennessee attorney general argue certain capital cases is constitutional, court rules
View Date:2024-12-24 00:49:32
MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) — A Tennessee law giving the appointed state attorney general authority to argue certain death penalty cases and removing that power from the hands of locally elected district attorneys is constitutional, an appeals court has ruled.
Tennessee’s Court of Criminal Appeals issued a decision Friday striking down a Shelby County judge’s ruling that the law passed by the state’s Republican-controlled Legislature was unconstitutional.
Passed in April 2023, the law allows the attorney general to step in and take over post-conviction capital cases. Judge Paula Skahan ruled later that year that the law did not follow the Tennessee Constitution because it removes the power of the locally elected district attorney to argue them.
The attorney general is an appointee picked by Tennessee’s Supreme Court.
Opponents of the law have called it an example of attempts by Republican governors and legislatures in several states to take on locally elected officials who have deprioritized enforcement of laws those officials deem unfair. Some attorneys and Democratic lawmakers have said the new law targets progressive district attorneys who have expressed reluctance to pursue the death penalty.
Meanwhile, attorneys for inmates fear the state could use the law to argue against considering DNA evidence and intellectual disabilities.
Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti, a Republican, appealed Skahan’s decision, which affects death row inmate Larry McKay’s motion for another trial based on new evidence. Shelby County District Attorney Steve Mulroy, who stepped into the case on behalf of McKay and other district attorneys across the state, said the matter “will ultimately be decided by the Tennessee Supreme Court.”
The law involves proceedings that are outside the traditional appeals process in death penalty cases. Those include going before a trial court to present new evidence, request DNA testing, or argue that a defendant has an intellectual disability. The attorney general oversees traditional appeals.
Skahan said that in trial court matters, the state constitution designates the district attorney as a state representative.
However, under the 2023 law, Skrmetti can replace Mulroy in McKay’s case. Mulroy supported McKay’s motion, which argued that the new law hinders the elected district attorney’s ability to fulfill his responsibilities.
McKay’s lawyer, Robert Hutton, filed the motion to disqualify Skrmetti from intervening. Hutton has said the law was an “overreach” by the Legislature.
The law’s sponsor, Republican state Sen. Brent Taylor, has said that district attorneys might be unfamiliar with the sometimes decades-old death penalty cases under appeal. That means the post-conviction challenges “lose their adversarial characteristic that ensures justice,” he said.
Taylor also said victims’ families would be better off communicating with just the attorney general’s office.
The appeals court ruling affects other cases in Tennessee in which death row inmates are challenging their convictions outside the appeals process. Although the Legislature cannot interfere with the district attorney’s “virtually unbridled prosecutorial discretion to initiate criminal prosecutions,” the state has long been represented by the attorney general in “proceedings collaterally attacking criminal convictions,” the appeals court said.
Skahan made a mistake in ruling that the law transferring representation from the locally elected district attorney to the attorney general was unconstitutional, the appeals court said.
In recent years, other district attorneys around the country have refused to prosecute cases related to some Republican-passed state laws, from voting restrictions to limits on protesting. In Georgia, Republican lawmakers passed a bill in 2023 establishing a commission to discipline and remove prosecutors who they believe aren’t sufficiently fighting crime.
Mulroy, in Memphis, and Davidson County District Attorney Glenn Funk, in Nashville, have said that they oppose the death penalty. State Sen. Raumesh Akbari, the Democratic minority leader, has said the law shouldn’t have been changed because of possible dislike for the “policies of our more liberal district attorneys.”
McKay was convicted of two murders during a robbery in Memphis and sentenced to death more than 40 years ago. His motion claims new scientific methods have revealed that the firearms evidence presented at his trial was unreliable.
His co-defendant, Michael Sample, was released from death row after he was found to be intellectually disabled.
veryGood! (3756)
Related
- 'I know how to do math': New Red Lobster CEO says endless shrimp deal is not coming back
- Bipartisan Tennessee proposal would ask voters to expand judges’ ability to deny bail
- NJ Transit scraps plan for gas-fired backup power plant, heartening environmental justice advocates
- New Hampshire veteran admits to faking his need for a wheelchair to claim $660,000 in extra benefits
- Olympic champion Lindsey Vonn is ending her retirement at age 40 to make a skiing comeback
- Kim Kardashian Reveals If Her Kids Will Take Over Her Beauty Empire
- AP Week in Pictures: Asia
- Small cargo plane crashes after takeoff from New Hampshire airport, pilot hospitalized
- Dramatic video shows Phoenix police rescue, pull man from car submerged in pool: Watch
- Relapse. Overdose. Saving lives: How a Detroit addict and mom of 3 is finding her purpose
Ranking
- Contained, extinguished and mopping up: Here’s what some common wildfire terms mean
- Ukrainians worry after plane crash that POW exchanges with Russia will end
- Kim Kardashian Reveals If Her Kids Will Take Over Her Beauty Empire
- U.N. slams Israel for deadly strike on Gaza shelter as war with Hamas leaves hospitals under siege
- 4 charged in Detroit street shooting that left 2 dead, 5 wounded
- NJ Transit scraps plan for gas-fired backup power plant, heartening environmental justice advocates
- Ake keeps alive Man City treble trophy defense after beating Tottenham in the FA Cup
- Winter Skincare From Kiehl's, Peter Thomas Roth & More That'll Bless Your Dry Skin From Head to Toe
Recommendation
-
Could trad wives, influencers have sparked the red wave among female voters?
-
New Hampshire veteran admits to faking his need for a wheelchair to claim $660,000 in extra benefits
-
Cyprus government unveils support measures for breakaway Turkish Cypriots ahead of UN envoy’s visit
-
Dominican judge orders conditional release of rapper Tekashi 6ix9ine in domestic violence case
-
Nicole Scherzinger receives support from 'The View' hosts after election post controversy
-
King Charles III Visits Kate Middleton as He Undergoes Procedure at Same Hospital
-
Justin Timberlake announces The Forget Tomorrow World Tour, his first tour in 5 years
-
Judge green-lights narrowing of main road through Atlantic City despite opposition from casinos